Tough “Irresponsible Dog Owner Laws” Spurned by Pit Bull Attacks
In the U.S., numerous local and state governments continue to look for the legislative answer, to both preventing dog attacks and holding the owners criminally responsible. According to a Philadelphia dog bite lawyer, Leonard Hill, 4.7 million people are victimized each year in dog attacks.
The problem of dog attacks on humans is not isolated to the United States.
Across the globe, in Melbourne, Australia, citizens are now demanding harsher fines and jail time for irresponsible dog owners after the slaughter of a 4-year-old girl in August 2011.
News.com.au reports that newly proposed legislation would provide for prison time, along with a fine of up to $30,000 if a person’s dog escapes and hurts or kills another person.
CourierMail.com performed a poll on August 18, 2011, asking readers, “Should dog owners be charged over attacks?” The response was overwhelmingly “Yes,” which was favored by 93.15% of respondents, compared to a “No” response from 6.85% of respondents.
Currently, Australian legislation allows irresponsible dog owners to face manslaughter charges, but Attorney General Paul Lucas would prefer to have specific legislation for prosecuting “irresponsible dog owners.”
As it stands, the drafted legislation holds owners responsible for managing their dogs and takes into account any past incidents where the dogs attacked humans. Also taken into consideration will be the dog’s training, temperament, whether restraint was appropriate in the circumstances, and whether the breed of dog was appropriate for protecting people or property.
By wording the language of this law in this manner, the law would theoretically prevent owners who responsibly managed their dogs from being mistakenly charged. If an owner fails to take appropriate steps to control their dog, however, he or she could be held criminally responsible and face up to 10 years in jail.
After a separate attack which killed a toddler, her five-year-old cousin, and aunt who attempted to help her, it become public knowledge that more than one-third of Queensland’s 73 councils either banned American Pit Bulls or would renew registration for the breed. Approximately 1900 restricted, dangerous, or menacing dogs are kept in Queensland.
The new legislation makes provisions for how these “restricted” dogs must be kept and is being followed by many other Queensland councils.

